Police Hiding in Plain Sight
On June 4,
2018 the Worcester Human Right Commission invited the Worcester Police
Department to present their views to the public. The Chair of the Worcester
Human Rights Commission said several time the Commission was a partner of the
police. The forum certainly reinforced this perception.
The
Worcester Human Rights Commission never said that it is a partner with the
concerned residents of the City. Some people who asked questions were lectured
about procedure. Other residents never spoke as the forum dragged on and people left.
I guess we should be happy that the police
shared any information with us.
Some of the
issues which the City police presented were:
1. Hate Crimes – After many years of
efforts by groups like the Massachusetts Human Rights Committee the police
finally release hate crime statistics. The police do not include
incidents that do not fit their profile in those statistics.
There were 10 hate crimes in Worcester in 2017. This number is so low it
strained my and others’ credulities
2. Body Cams – the Police Chief said that this
was in “process”, but he could not name the next event in the process nor the
date of the next event
3. Diversity – The Police claimed to
have a program geared toward student. However the police are compelled to hire
veterans before all others in the State mandated affirmative action for
veterans. Almost all successful police recruits are veterans.
4. Horse Patrol – The police said that
their horse patrols has a positive effect. Unfortunately the police could not
give any evidence of the usefulness of horse patrols.
The cost of the four horses, truck, trailer, and minimum of 3 officers on
a single assignment, stable, etc. is
over a half million dollars. So far
there has only been anecdotal stories of how kids liking horses. There has been
no quantitative evaluation of the useful of horses by the police.
5. The issue of complaints against
police officers was presented in the best light for the police. There were few
complaints last year. Most of the complaints made by civilians were not
sustained. Most of the complaints made by Police commanders were sustained. The police presented this as evidence that the
police can police the police.
There might be a need for an independent auditor to evaluate all of the
City’s Department including the police department.
Two concerned residents spoke of the trauma suffered by students as a
result of interactions with the police. For
the elementary school children the trauma is the result of an older person
adverse treatment by the police. She indicated that such trauma has been
treated at Community Healthlink.
Another concerned resident point out the negative experiences of high
school student with the police. She felt it was a factor in the so called
School to Jail Pipelne that some characterized as racists.
I am not sure that any one in the City government is really listening or
able to make effective policy.